Cruise Line Excursions vs DIY Tours: What’s Best?

South Beach Key West
Share

Today we are exploring whether it’s better to book Cruise Line Excursions vs DIY: What’s Best? We have been on many cruises, with and without our children (who are now grown up and still cruise with us) and do not always do the planned tour excursions. We have taken many excursions with various cruise lines and mostly had great experiences. Plus, we’ve explored ports independently more times than I care to count, and we mostly choose this approach. Here, we will look at the pros and cons of exploring independently versus booking tours via the ship.

After hours spent researching cruise lines, different cabins and cruise itineraries, you’ve finally booked your cruise. If you think you can now sit back, relax and dream about sipping a cocktail as your ship sails away, sorry to burst your bubble.  The planning is just about to start!  To ensure you make the most of your cruise, you now need to plan your time ashore.

AD | We have been or could be if you click on a link in this post compensated via a cash payment, gift or something else of value for writing this post. As an Amazon Associate and Stay 22 we earn from qualifying purchases. See our full disclosure policy and privacy policy for more details.

Sometimes, it’s easier to do a port trip independently rather than book an expensive cruise tour that might not meet your expectations. We look at when it’s better to explore alone and when a port tour is worth it.

Cruise Line Excursions vs DIY Exploring: What Choices Do You Have?

There are several choices, all with different levels of cost and ease. When travelling with kids, we have found that easy always wins. Lengthy tours can be more trouble than they are worth; children want to be back on the ship, enjoying the facilities. So we have always negotiated ship and port time. To manage this research is key to know where you want to go and what you want to see.

You Have Three Choices

So what should you do? 

This All Depends On The Port

It depends on the port itself, the proximity of where your cruise ship docks, the nearest town/attractions and how you want to fill your day. If the port is an hour from the place you want to visit, you need to factor in transfers, risk and timings. For example, Rome is often worth paying extra for a tour, given the cost of local guides and transfers.

It also depends on how much effort you are prepared to put into researching the port or whether you would prefer to jump on a tour bus and leave it to the experts. However, if you dock near a town, then it’s worth doing the research and self-exploring.

Cruise ports with kids how to survive

You Can Save Money on Cruise Line Excursions, Exploring Independently and Booking A Local Guide

We use Get Your Guide for all our local tours. It’s important to check that any local tour guides you book have a cancellation policy. Ships sometimes cancel ports, so it’s better to have that option. However, local guides have more insight into ports and areas. We always get so much more from a tour with a local guide.

Advantages Of Booking Shore Excursions With A Local Guide

This is all about convenience, especially when you are cruising with kids: there is no need to plan or worry about any logistics. Just jump on board your mode of transportation (coach, local port train or boat) and be shown the highlights of an area by an experienced guide.  This is particularly great when travelling with kids because, let’s be honest, anything that makes life easier when travelling with kids is a winner!

You’ll get to learn about the port along the way, rather than just being dropped off as you would in a taxi. With an informative guide sharing local insights, it becomes part of the experience. The Conch Train Tour in Key West is a great example, and many ports offer similar family-friendly tours.

The Conch Tour Trains in Key West

Will The Ship Leave Without You?

If you think this is a rumour circulated to encourage you to book shore excursions, you’re mistaken.  We have witnessed several passengers being left behind because they arrived late on the ship.

Always, ALWAYS carry your ship’s daily newsletter (It is usually on the app too) with you for port-agent contact details in case this happens to you, plus a photocopy of your passport. Triple-check the ship’s departure time before you disembark for the day.  It’s also really important to check whether your watch is set to local time or ship time. The ship will only wait for people on organised tours with the cruise ship. So if you explore independently, plan to get back at least an hour earlier than you need to.

Just Get Of The Ship And Wing It

There are many cruise ports you can explore independently with no tour. If you are travelling with kids, this is often a great option. So whilst you can book tours, buses and trains. You can also choose a slower pace. Pick one activity and pre-book, or just go for ice cream, lunch and shopping.

All ports have parks where children can run off some energy, which is always a welcome break on a busy day ashore. If, like our boys, your kids are football-mad, we also try to include stadium tours where possible, or to go in search of local club shops and kits. It’s become a bit of a tradition for us, with the kids saving up their pocket money specifically for a new shirt from each destination.

Ovre Holmegate in Stavanger

We have also always had a family rule that everyone had to try a new local dish in every country we visited. This became an adventure we followed on every trip, promising fabulous family lunches in many locations.

Cruise Ports That Are Easy To Walk Off And Explore Independly

Of course, there are more, but this gives an idea of how easy it is to explore cruise ports independently. Not all, but many are easy to do and offer plenty of family-friendly activities.

Where to Eat Riomaggiore

Cruise Line Excursions: What Are The Benefits

There are some occasions where it’s just easier to book a cruise excursion. Sometimes a cruise port is too far away or on a difficult route. These are the times I would book direct.

Rome is a train and bus ride away from the port, and if a return train is cancelled, it can be a challenge to get back. However, you can book Rome on your own tours, where you are dropped off and picked up to come back to the ship. Full-day tours are also available, and we have done this, but it was on a coach with 50 people, and the guide told us her life story throughout the day, then asked for a tip. This put me off full-day tours; I felt herded, restricted and sold, too. I want to explore a cruise port on my terms.

Saying that most cruise lines offer transfers for on your own tours to places like Florence, Rome, Pisa, and these can save you considerable stress if the attraction is a distance from the cruise port.

Cruise Line Excursions Offer Help In The Case of an Emergency

 You can rest assured that if there is an emergency during a cruise ship shore excursion, your guide and driver will liaise with the ship and make all the necessary arrangements. And if the tour is delayed, the ship will wait for you if you are on a cruise line excursion.

However, if you experience difficulties while exploring ashore independently, it will be up to you to get back to the port in time. If the ship has already left, you will need to contact the port agent to arrange to pick up your passport and pay for flights to meet the ship in a future port of call.

A family trip to Lisbon

Cruise Line Excursions or DIY Exploring: What’s Best?

No matter how you choose to explore the cruise port, and how old your family is. Cruising is a holiday that will grow with you; ports offer so many treasures that guarantee returning again and again, is never dull. There is always something new to explore. My advice is to start building Instagram folders for the cruise ports you plan to visit, by the time you travel you will have a list of adventures ready to explore.

Author

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.